Best Cradle Swing – Snugabunny Swing or Papasan Swing

With so many options available, finding the best cradle swing is extremely difficult. I looked at a number of different things, including features, prices, and customer feedback. What I found was that two cradle swings is better than one. In other words, I couldn’t decide between the Fisher Price My Little Snugabunny Cradle Swing and the Fisher Price Papasan Cradle Swing, so I’ve decided to list them both. Let me explain why I think these two are the best cradle swings.

Fisher Price My Little Snugabunny Cradle Swing
Fisher Price My Little Snugabunny Cradle Swing

First of all, let’s take a look at the Fisher Price My Little Snugabunny Cradle Swing. This one had the highest customer satisfaction percentage. With 114 out of 131 reviewers rating it 4 to 5 stars, with 5 being the max. In other words, 87% were extremely satisfied. What I like most about the Snugabunny Cradle Swing is the nest like appearance. The seat is deep with extra soft fill, and it’s lined with micro fiber for superior comfort. It comes with removable infant side supports, runs on both batteries and an AC adapter, and offers a cute little motorized over-head mobile with hanging birdies and a dome mirror. All too often you get a great swing with a crappy mobile, and in this case, the mobile is perfect. The Snugabunny Swing also offers  2 reclining seat positions, 6 speeds, 8 melodies, and 2 nature sounds. Your little one can swing either side-to-side or head-to-toe. The Snugabunny Swing is also affordable, and it’s currently listed on Amazon for $126.98, that’s 23% off and a good deal.

Fisher Price Papasan Cradle Swing
Fisher Price Papasan Cradle Swing

My other pick for best cradle swing is the Fisher Price Papasan Cradle Swing. This one had the most customer reviews, so it seems to be the best selling. With 1190 reviewers out of 1452 rating it 4 to 5 stars, that’s 82% pure customer satisfaction. Let me quickly explain that anything in the 80’s percentage wise is really, really good. You very rarely see a baby swing with a higher percentage than 90%, that just goes to show that you can’t please everybody, and every baby is different. Some like to swing fast, others slow.  So when I say, 82% customer satisfaction, that means that 82% of the reviewers were extremely satisfied. Okay, let’s move on and examine the Papasan Cradle Swing. First of all, my absolute favorite feature is the over-head mobile. It’s a light show! The mobile rotates around with three hanging toys, and it has lights that actually reflect off the canopy that surrounds your little one. My daughter would have loved this! The Papasan Cradle Swing also runs on batteries or with an AC adapter. It offers a removable tray with a toy bead bar to further entertain your little one, plus it also offers 2 reclining positions. Baby can swing either head-to-toe, or side-to-side, and listen to 16 different melodies, both daytime and nighttime melodies.  The Papasan Cradle Swing also offers 6 speeds, and folds for storage. It’s not the least expensive of cradle swings, but I still think it’s priced really well for all that you get. It’s currently listed at Amazon for $149.99.

If you’re interested in either of these cradle swings, the Snugabunny or the Papasan, check out the full reviews listed below for more information.

The Fisher Price Papasan Cradle Swing Review

The Fisher Price Snugabunny Cradle Swing Review & Video Demo

The Fisher Price Papasan Cradle Swing Vs. The Zen Collection Cradle Swing

Fisher Price is the leading manufacturer of some of the best cradle swings. So it’s no surprise if you’re having trouble deciding between a couple. For instance, if you happen to be comparing the Fisher Price Papasan Cradle Swing with the Fisher Price Zen Collection Cradle Swing, you might have a tough time deciding. Let me help you make an educated decision.

Fisher Price Papasan Cradle Swing - Butterfly Garden
Fisher Price Papasan Cradle Swing - Butterfly Garden

Similarities:

First let’s look at what they have in common. Both the Papasan Cradle Swing and the Zen Collection Cradle Swing offer 2 swinging motions, side-to-side and head-to-toe, 6 soothing speeds, 3-point restraint, and a comfy seat with 2 reclining positions. Both the Zen Collection and Papasan Cradle Swings are battery operational and come with an AC adapter to plug into the wall. Both also have a max weight capacity of 25 pounds.

Differences:

Fisher Price Zen Collection Cradle Swing
Fisher Price Zen Collection Cradle Swing @ Amazon $129.00

Features –As for the differences, the Papasan Cradle Swing offers 16 different songs, both daytime and nighttime modes, whereas the Zen Collection Cradle Swing offers 14 classical and lullaby style songs along with 2 sound effect tracks. The Papasan Cradle Swing comes with a removable tray and toy bead bar, rotating mobile, tailored sheer canopy, and overhead light show that projects onto the canopy.The Zen Collection Cradle Swing comes in beautiful rich colors with wood accents, and offers an overhead mobile that moves with the swing, machine washable attached blankets and pillow, as well as a removable infant seat that you can carry around the house with you.

Fisher Price Zen Collection Cradle Swing Infant Seat
Fisher Price Zen Collection Cradle Swing Infant Seat

Reviews – As for reviews, the Fisher Price Papasan Cradle Swing is definitely the most popular, with 1,079 out of 1,307 reviewers giving it 4 to 5 stars out of 5. Most love it, and even stated that they couldn’t live without it. There were a few complaints, most were older, that said they had a defective motor. However, Fisher Price was quick to replace any bad parts. The Fisher Price Zen Collection Cradle Swing had 128 out of 171 reviewers give it 4 to 5 stars, stating that their most loved feature was the removable infant seat. One reviewer stated that when her daughter fell asleep, she would frequently remove the seat and carry her around the house while she did housework. The only real complaints that I found were that the assembly instructions were hard to follow, and that the swing took up quite a bit of space, but most Cradle Swings do.

Price –The Fisher Price Zen Collection Cradle Swing is regularly priced at $224.99, however it is currently on sale at Amazon.com for $129.99, 43% OFF! The Fisher Price Papasan Cradle Swing is regularly listed for $169.99, however it is currently on sale at Amazon.com for $118.00 in Butterfly Garden! That’s 26% OFF!

Conclusion:

The Fisher Price Papasan Cradle Swing is about $22.00 dollars cheaper and it comes with a rotating mobile, removable toy tray, and overhead light show. On the other side of the fence, the Fisher Price Zen Collection Cradle Swing is more expensive, but you also get a beautiful, richly colored swing with wood accents, and a removable infant seat that can be easily carried from room to room. Now you have to decide which features are more important to you. If you’re still undecided, take a look at the following links for FULL reviews.

Additional Reading:

The Fisher Price Zen Collection Cradle Swing Review

The Fisher Price Papasan Cradle Swing Review

Best Baby Swings: The Fisher Price Papasan Swing Review

Fisher-Price Papasan Swing Review

Overall Rating:
Fisher-Price Papasan Cradle Swing
Fisher-Price Papasan Cradle Swing

At Amazon for $99.00 – 48% OFF

Skip To:

Description:

The Fisher-Price Papasan Swing offers both the head-to-toe traditional swinging motion, and the side-to-side cradle motion, as well as 6 soothing speeds. The comfy, cozy seat offers two reclining positions, as well as a 3 point restraint to keep your baby safe and secure. The Papasan Swing also has two music modes, daytime, and nighttime, with 16 songs total, and two sound effects. The rotating mobile offers three soft toys, and an overhead light show that projects onto the tailored sheer canopy. The Papsan Swing also offers a removable snack tray with a toy bead bar. The seat pad is also removable and machine washable, and the sturdy steel frame folds for easy storage and portability. The Fisher Price Papasan Swing comes with an AC adapter that will plug-in to any outlet, and also has the ability to run on battery power.

Features and Specifications:

Fisher-Price Papasan Cradle Swing
Fisher-Price Papasan Cradle Swing
  • 2 swinging motions: head-to-toe and side-to-side
  • 6 possible speeds
  • Cozy papasan seat with 2 reclining positions
  • 3-point restraint
  • 16 different songs with 2 music modes, daytime, and nighttime
  • Removable tray with toy bead bar
  • Rotating mobile with 3 toys
  • Overhead light show that projects onto the canopy
  • Tailored sheer canopy
  • Seat pad is removable and machine washable.
  • AC adapter that plugs into any outlet
  • Battery operational (4 D batteries)
  • Age: Birth to 6 months or 25 pounds
  • Sturdy steel frame folds for storage
  • The Papasan cradle swing dimensions in Inches (L x W x H): 36.0 x 30.0 x 40.0

 Get The Fisher-Price Papasan Cradle Swing – 48% OFF @ Amazon.com


Reviews:

As for reviews, the Fisher Price Papasan Swing did really well, with 1,079 out of 1,307 reviewers rating it 4 to 5 stars, with a max of 5. In other words, about 83% of the reviewers were extremely pleased with their purchase. As far as the bad reviews go, most were older and pertain to older models, but a few of the newer ones complained about a defective motor, which was then replaced by Fisher-Price. All in all, most of the reviewers loved the Papasan Swing, and would recommend it to anyone. See below what some of the current owners had to say about their Papasan Swing.

Or check out the comparison reviews at the bottom of this page.


Customer Feedback:

You won’t find a better swing,June 16, 2011

By texamomma,

This is my first review but I felt like after the hundreds of dollars that we’ve spent on baby items this one is by far above and beyond and deserves some recognition. I started out with the bright starts comfort and harmony swing (we have a fairly small house so I was trying to find a small compact swing that could fold and be tucked away easily). After a nightmare of a swing the fisher price papasan swing came to the rescue. My son is 5 months old and in about the 50th percentile for weight and this swing still is staying strong. The seat looks so comfy I just want to curl up next to him. I read a few reviews about the motor being loud, and I don’t agree, this is actually fairly quiet I think. ALL swings make some noise. I have tried out friends as well as the one at grandma’s house and this seat is awesome it is the only one he will sit in for longer than 15 seconds. This seat is more like an extra comfy car-seat in that it has a plastic frame/bucket which supports under the babies while a lot of baby swings just have fabric pulled across a metal frame creating a sink hole for the infant to sit in with no support. I wish I could convince everyone to at least try this swing.

 

A Must-Have Baby Product,May 26, 2011

By WatermarkedOne,

This Fisher Price Cradle Swing has been a life and sanity saver for us! We have the Papasan Swing in Starlight. My son falls asleep so easily in this–it soothes him almost immediately.

Pros:
1. It swings in two directions: side to side and front to back. I’ve heard many babies prefer one way over the other, but you can’t know before baby tries it so we wanted one that goes both ways. Our son much prefers front to back, but if we have more children and they prefer side to side we’ll still be all set.

2. It is round and nest-like, which I think makes him feel secure. I’ve heard this type of swing is very helpful for colicky babies. If he gets gas at night and doesn’t want to be flat on his back in his crib we’ll bring it into the bedroom and he usually falls right asleep.

3. The motor is quiet. There is a “swish, click” sound, but I think it’s soothing to my son and I have no trouble reading or napping with it going.

4. It can run on batteries or plug in. We can take it on our porch on nice evenings, and since we plan to move overseas this is a nice feature.

5. The music isn’t annoying, although I’ve gotten a little tired of it. It is a mix of classical songs, nursery rhymes, and some songs I don’t recognize. The nature sounds are also soothing to my son.

6. It’s beautiful! We have it in our living room and I didn’t want anything with garish primary colors. It fits right in with our gray-blue and brown living room. The blue is a little purpley, so it could easily be a girl or boy’s swing.

7. The net helps prevent my dog from sniffing/licking the baby’s face (something I am paranoid about!)

Cons:
1. I wish it had a central on/off switch. There are six buttons to control speed, music, mobile, etc. It would be nice if one switch turned it all off and you could switch it on to go back to the previous settings.

2. The mobile is a little boring–it has two stuffed stars and a teddy bear. The soft pastel colors are beautiful but don’t catch my son’s eye.

3. You can move the headrest up and down, but I wish it was removable (it’s sewed in with a tab and has different velcro positions). It works great now (my son is 6 weeks old), but as he gets taller I think it might get in the way.

This is by far my favorite baby product; if we could only have one thing this would be it. I’m sure we would BOTH spend a lot of time curled up in the fetal position crying if it wasn’t for the Fisher Price Papasan Swing! You can’t put a price on a product that helps your baby sleep.

See all customer reviews…….

Get The Fisher Price Papasan Cradle Swing – Best Price 48% OFF

Comparison Reviews:

Papasan Swing Vs. Zen Collection Swing

Back to Top